This Week in the Digital Photography School Forums (7-13 Nov ’10)
Weekly Assignment
T
his week’s assignment took a trip back to the basics by looking at the Rule of Thirds. This is a compositional rule that suggests that you put your subject on one of the lines that divides the image into thirds. Our winner this week was sunwrites‘s keyboard image. The blue tint really works well with the graphical nature of this image. And there’s an interesting touch of the 3 being right on one of the “thirds” lines. Our first runner up was BarbaraAnn‘s Hard Rock Cafe photo. This one makes good use of angles and lines, and you can see that the guitar of the sign lies right along one of the “thirds” lines. And last, but not least is dukesg‘s City Lights. With this one, there are great colours and reflection and you can still see just a hint of colour in the sky. In this one, you can see that it’s the horizon that runs along the “thirds” line. Well done everyone!

After spending time following the rule of thirds, this week’s assignment is now Breaking the Rule of Thirds Sometimes an image is much stronger if it doesn’t follow the rule of thirds. Not every shot works well, but sometimes shots can gain symmetry or even just take advantage of having a strong subject in the middle of the frame. But keep in mind, don’t just break the rule without a reason, we want to see shots that use it well. As always, a quick reminder of the rules. First your photo must have been taken between 3-17 November 2010. Second, your post must include the words “Assignment: Break the Rule of Thirds” and the date that the photo was taken. Finally, your EXIF should be intact, and it’s useful if you can include some of the main points, such as camera, lens, aperture, shutter speed, ISO, etc. Next week we will be working on another compositional tool, this time we will be Filling the Frame. So get rid of all the distractions and fill the frame with your subject.




8 Responses to “This Week in the Digital Photography School Forums (7-13 Nov ’10)” - Add Yours
November 14th, 2010 at 1:44 am
Hi
I love the results of the Rule of Thirds assignment. Great composition and intriguing subjects! I think the Rule actually spawns from the mathematical Fibonacci Sequence, DaVinci used this all the time in his work. Practically it is how nature behaves, an if you just offset your focal item from the Thirds intersection, it makes it more “Natural” to the eye, because that is the way of the world. I tried to do this with this image with the lamps at the Fibonacci point. http://tinyurl.com/264hv4d
regards, Erik
November 14th, 2010 at 4:04 am
here is my attempt. Not sure if it fits though. http://tinyurl.com/2eg88dg
November 14th, 2010 at 9:57 pm
” a compositional rule that suggests that you put your subject on one of the lines that divides the image into thirds”
I’ve never been a fan of rule-based composition. I think it’s restrictive and narrow. Much better that you put your subject where it looks right.
November 15th, 2010 at 11:47 pm
My 3rd attempt for “Assignment: Break the Rule of Thirds”
November 15th, 2010 at 11:49 pm
“Assignment: Break the Rule of Thirds”
http://www.flickr.com/photos/lifeisshortdrinkfast/5174718863/in/photostream/
November 17th, 2010 at 3:53 pm
Let’s break the rules
Canon 50D
Canon EF-S18-55 IS (shot at 18mm)
ISO 100
Exposure 13sec at f / 3.5
Location Antigua Guatemala, Guatemala
November 18th, 2010 at 6:24 am
Breaking the rules
http://www.flickr.com/photos/robsacasa/5165331816/
DPS
“Assignment: Break the Rule of Thirds”
Canon 50D
Canon EF-S18-55 IS (shot at 18mm)
ISO 100
Exposure 13sec at f / 3.5
Location Antigua Guatemala, Guatemala
April 6th, 2011 at 4:40 am
Hi, what is your last name because i would like to compare your keyboard photo for my school a-level project as it is similar to one of mine and i must state the full name of the person. I would be very appreciative. Many thanks, Daisy
Leave a Reply