Help! #2

[plangereis]

Here is the second set, which are landscapes I am considering entering in the same competition as my last post. I only want one of the following so please help me choose which one. Any comments are always welcome, good or bad. I will most likely tweak the chosen photo a bit more.

Closing on Lytton


Malaspina Galleries


Seton Lake


Silva Bay

[omis]

They are all very nice but the second one is my fave

[Ryan O Hill]

wow! i think number2,but 3 and 4 are wicked too. nice job!

[beachcomber]

Hello Paul, in the absence of the b+w version, Malaspina Galleries gets my vote
Steve

[leonaashlee]

I really like the second one as well, but my next favorite would be the fourth. Good luck

[peeperita]

i like the seton lake image......something about the blue mountains and the sense of depth......

peeper

[Fred flyfisher]

These are all really good... Hard choice to make but, I like #1 and #2 the most.

[plangereis]

Originally Posted by omis

They are all very nice but the second one is my fave

Originally Posted by Ryan O Hill

wow! i think number2,but 3 and 4 are wicked too. nice job!

Originally Posted by beachcomber

Hello Paul, in the absence of the b+w version, Malaspina Galleries gets my vote
Steve

Originally Posted by peeperita

i like the seton lake image......something about the blue mountains and the sense of depth......

peeper

Originally Posted by Fred flyfisher

These are all really good... Hard choice to make but, I like #1 and #2 the most.

Thanks again to all of you who have provided input so far. This is a tough one as there is no real consensus like there was in my last series. I will wait until I get a few more responses, but at this point Malaspina Galleries is on top. Thanks again for your valuable input.

[PrimeTime]

I think i like the second one the best.

[lindyannajones]

What is with the folks at DPS? Something about fallen logs has a kind of tug. Without editing--number 2. Why? The eye seems to like diagonal lines and the logs keep your eye moving, log by log, to the horizon. I wonder if it has to do with the pace of eye movement? In addition to the appeal of fallen logs, though, is the distant island which for me relates to longing. Endings and beginnings? Doesn't matter--just musings--bottom line, I really like number two.