Which would you choose??

[rlindemuth]

Been taking kitchen utensil shots for the weekly assignment.....having trouble picking which one to use? Opinions would be greatly appreciated.

My Heart Overfloweth.....


Whisk in a silver bowl.....


Whisk 2....


Reflection in a Grater....


Thanks in advance!!
More shots at http://www.flickr.com/photos/37076666@N08/

[pjflan7]

the 2nd shot looks to me to be the strongest photo you have....The 3rd is confusing....can't tell what I am looking at.....part of photo 1 is obvious and the rest of the shot is a bit abstract. The 4th would be my second choice but it looks like the camera moved just a hair.....at least to my eyes.......like the concept though.

[rlindemuth]

Thanks for your opinion.....I guess I was going for abstract....maybe I ought to keep it clean and simple.

[dlalonde]

#2 would be my choice. Good luck.

[Hadianto Sumantri]

i choose #2, it's simpler, easy recognizeable focus of interest

[lyacadajar]

#2 is perfect - go for it!

[kencaleno]

none-they are all blurred/out of focus. Ken

[rlindemuth]

Thanks for all of your opinions....I suppose back to the drawing board. I was going for something different showing movement in the silver bowl.....guess it didn't work to well lol oh well still learning.

[harrypalmer044]

Hi there,
nice to see you on here again, I too like No2 best but feel it could do with a little sharpening (maybe just my poor eyesight). I like the feel on No 1 but feel No 2 is simple yet effective. Hope this help's.
David.

[rlindemuth]

Thank you to everyone for your opinions, from them, I realized these pics were not great at all.....so rather than get discouraged, I pulled out my tripod and my external flash. Just recieved the email today about repetition in photography so decided to go with the grater idea......I feel much better about this one.