Is this overdone? HDR

[luismr]

Couple friends told me it´s way too much PP.

I would like to know what do you think.
Thanks in advance,

[windrider86]

I saw this posted somewhere else and thought hmmmmmmmmmmmm
what matters is if you like it.
I personally am not fond of the pink hues

[ntinlizi]

i like it. the colors are very bold and vibrant! i think that it fits, seeing as india is a very colorful culture! although im not sure where this was taken but it seems to be an indian style building. its beautiful!

[Murtasma]

I think it's over processed. It lacks shadows and highlights. It's colorful yes but it lacks depth.

[digirebelva]

For some. its bordering on the cartoonish look..sometimes less is more..

[mhuk05]

I like some HDR (which itself is an acquired taste) but I don't think it works because of the sky - it is a block of bright blue- and the contrast is quite strong (too strong, IMO) with the building. I'm trying to quantify what it is that makes me think "hmm.. I don't like it". I preferred images 4 and 10 on smugmug.

HTH

[luismr]

Originally Posted by windrider86

I saw this posted somewhere else and thought hmmmmmmmmmmmm
what matters is if you like it.
I personally am not fond of the pink hues

Hi windrider86,
I liked... that´s a fact, I like the way the color pops.

Thanks for looking.

[luismr]

Originally Posted by ntinlizi

i like it. the colors are very bold and vibrant! i think that it fits, seeing as india is a very colorful culture! although im not sure where this was taken but it seems to be an indian style building. its beautiful!

Hi ntinlizi,
Thanks for your feedback, I´m very glad you like it.

[luismr]

Originally Posted by Murtasma

I think it's over processed. It lacks shadows and highlights. It's colorful yes but it lacks depth.

Hi Murtasma,
Oh yes... it is very colorful and it has some, just some shadows...

Thanks for your feedback

[torqueguru]

I kinda like it! It looks more 2D to me though, but its a very different HDR...a painting sorta thing. I feel one thing though, the over bright ares give that neonish feel which i personally didn't enjoy much, as i feel detail is lost there. May be you could tome down the saturation a bit....just maybe. Any how great effort!
Regards,
TG.