Which Polarizing Filter?

[Twinpanther]

After seeing Scooter Pie's image with a Polarizing Filter it convinced me I need to have one of these in my bag but after looking at them there is quite a difference between brands and price. OK, I get that I need a Circular of Linear and thinner is better with quality glass but what else should I be looking for?

I'm looking at the 67mm Hoya Pro1 but if you folks have a better idea or I'm overlooking something I'd love your suggestions.

Thanks,
Twin

[Jim Bryant]

Make sure it's circular type and made of glass instead of plastic. I'd rather spend the extra money for quality instead of going cheap. I use a B + W circular filter, which costs me between 70 and 100.00. It's thin, so I can use it on every lens from the 16-35mm to 28-70 to 70-200mm.

[Twinpanther]

Thank you Jim. My sentiments exactly about quality. After your recommendation and reading up a bit it looks like it will be B&W for me as well.

Again, thank you for taking the time to post!

Twin

[Krusty79]

I've heard B+W is the best. Hoya if you're on a budget.

[Izzy]

I use a Bower CPL. I am sure Jim will tell you I shoot through a turd

[Twinpanther]

Nice to hear that, Krusty. The Hoya I was considering was $90 delivered and I found the B&W for $96.50 delivered. That was a no brainer. Not to mention the 10 year warranty on the B&W CPL!

[Krusty79]

I admit I still have the kit 18-55 lens with a cheap Sunpak CPL. I am debating whether it is worth spending the $90 to get a B+W one when that's about the cost of my lens! If it's that close in price to the Hoya, I might bite the bullet and get one. Aw, crap, I guess I'll have to and hope the lens I eventually replace my 18-55 with also takes the same filter size.

The reviews about the B+W ones say they are high quality brass and they immediately feel like a well-made product.

[Twinpanther]

If you are interested, NWV Direct is where I found the best price.

Make sure you go for the slim glass.