one or two? u decide

[lynnphotography]

I would like to know which is better. I can't decide. I would also like any comments on lighting, composition, and any other tips you may be able to provide. Thanks in advance

EXIF Data:

Kodak Easyshare C182

Shutter Speed 1/8 sec.
Aperture F/2.9
Focal Length: 6mm
ISO Speed: 250

[Hartzler]

It's a tough call. Because I have no strong preference as between the two, I would pick the first. You have finer eyelash detail that is lost in the processing of the second. In terms of composition, I would get rid of the dark object in the upper right corner. It adds nothing to the shot (unlike the bottle, which is great) and is a mild distraction. There's a little shadow in the lower cheek. I can't tell you what kind of lighting to use to remove it in this kind of shot, but ideally, I think you'd have a more even lighting for a baby shot of this nature.

It's a beautiful shot. I'd be happy to have taken it, very sweet. My critiques are simply a few ideas to consider in future shots.