A girl and her dog

[AnneWynne]

Another close-up of a young girl, this time with a dog.
What do you think of the composition and crop to 8 by 10 (it tood out a lot of the sea marsh to her left.)


The original uncropped is

Thanks,
Anne

[freybear3]

i actually like the uncropped version better.

[Rolling Stone]

I like the cropped better. Makes for a better composition.

[SusanH1970]

I prefer the cropped as well. My eyes went straight to hers. In the uncropped, I noticed the horizon first.

[praline3001]

I guess I am an odd duck as I like the uncropped better in this particular photo ... but what do I know I am new LOL

My reasoning is the proportions of her face are off with the cropped version. Her face (cheeks mostly) are out of proportion with the rest of her body.

The photo is very cute.... and I do like both versions but I prefer the uncropped over the two

[pfgroa]

uncropped. Although the image is good, now that I've seen the uncropped I think that it looks better with a bit more room.

and the sea marsh is blurry so it's not distracting.

[crownofstorms]

I like the uncropped version better! Gives it more room to breathe.