Vignette or not?

[NicoleScraps]

I am working on edits for a recent senior session and am looking for opinions on the vignette in this photo. For the record, I am not normally a fan of vignettes, but with this particular photo, I think that it might work.
What do you think? Vignette? No vignette? Vignette yes but change it to ______? And why?

Thanks so much!

[zona5101]

Vignette! Just make it more subtle. I like it so it is barely noticable, just a hint to darken the corners and focus the eye to the center.

[SusanH1970]

LOL...I like the one without much better.

[phil24]

I think the one without makes her look separated from the background and the one with makes the background look as if it is intended to be a part of the picture. I would say it depends on which look you were trying for, but I like the vignette, perhaps slightly lighter would get that happy medium.

[Indigo November]

Without. Much better. It looks a little cheesy with. The biggest thing is her legs though. They look super tanned!

[BuddhaPi]

I prefer the one without..

[Matthew_Scullion]

You could try and darken lighten centre filter instead of a vignette perhaps, e.g. in Nik Software Color Efex Pro?

[Rentham]

The vignette doesn't make sense to me. Typically a vignette is intended to draw attention to the subject. Here, shot on white, the subject is the only point of contrast in the photo. There's nothing competing with her. All the vignette is doing for me here is making the corners look dirty.