colours.. which one better

[wal]

original pic non edit..


edited

I am wandering, which one do you prefer and most importantly why..?
I'd Love to hear some oppinions. It doesnt have to be all technical and all just simple expression can do. Thnks.. any suggestions are welcomed..


Tv( Shutter Speed ) 20sec
Av( Aperture Value ) 10
ISO Speed 250

[IrisEyes]

Hi Wal:

I prefer the unedited photo. The edited version shows what looks like pink noise in the sky and on the mountains, at least on my monitor. Detail seems to have been lost on the far shoreline and in the lights on the pier. I love the mood of the first one.

IrisEyes

[RecurrentNerve]

First one. Second one looks like there was a bright streetlight just off-camera.

[AznFX]

First one definitely. It feels more natural and appealing.

[Eileen D]

I absolutely agree that the first is a stronger image. The light in the second doesn't look as natural as the first.

[Lemonface]

Really like the first one. The reflection in the second one looks like fire rather than a glow, which I don't think was the intention.

[Barbsjoy]

not very original of me... but I like the first one better as well. Second edited shot has an artificial look to me.

[Essy]

I like the first one best too. The dark tones of the sky make the lights really pop. Beautiful picture.