girl portrait (which processing?)

[Pitrih]

hello

i would love to get some feedback about post processing i did.
after making this one tanya | Flickr - Photo Sharing!
i wanted to edit other shots in the same style,
but i'm not sure if it works well on this photo bellow...i kinda liked b&w too, can't decide :P



or suggest improvements!

exif data
f 2.8
iso 200
1/1000

[carlyfan]

I like the first one better. Nice shot.

[rcastillo]

i'm with carly..

[Pitrih]

thanks! i think i'm convinced now
after looking at it the next day with fresh eyes helped too.