PDA

View Full Version : Comparison - Critique


Pages : 1 [2] 3 4

  1. Visions of a lost age
  2. The Scream - Better in Colour or B&W
  3. Color or B&W
  4. Waterfalls
  5. First time post processing
  6. Darker or lighter
  7. how would you crop this shot?
  8. Tones and overtones
  9. "The" Question - B/W or Color...?
  10. My friend's portraits - my first attempt. Critics welcome
  11. Horse grazing, comparing crops
  12. Do you like this style?
  13. Night of Day Shot?
  14. Rolling Stone
  15. question about color/saturation?
  16. Would like some honest criticism
  17. which one
  18. My youngest daughter
  19. Color vs. B&W
  20. B&W or Color
  21. cropping/saturation question boy with umbrella
  22. Does the crop still work
  23. Warm or cool -- can't decide.
  24. White Balance Issues
  25. to edit or not to edit, that is the ?
  26. why cant i post?
  27. Hearts
  28. DOF in the city
  29. Poker night fun, but....
  30. Color composition
  31. Wings
  32. Natural color or artifical tone?
  33. Another closed factory
  34. Cormorant
  35. crop
  36. child portrait
  37. Comparison, trying to fix blown out background
  38. 2 bllue herons: is one better than the other?
  39. A bridal portrait
  40. Which one I have to choose
  41. kids at a corfu wedding
  42. Desaturation and Wedding collections
  43. Is this a composition? I mean my face!
  44. Which one should I pick?
  45. The Meh Factor
  46. Pink and Fluffy.
  47. Bride Touch Up
  48. Street Photography Foray
  49. Sunset Edit- input/help wanted
  50. Choosing from three different photographs
  51. Trying to make my picture look like Ashley McNamura's photography
  52. Lomography vs Cross Processing!
  53. Where did I go wrong?
  54. Breaking the Rules - Does it work
  55. Which crop?
  56. I need you critic please...
  57. Windswept and Interesting?
  58. Before and After PSE6
  59. A very grave issue
  60. Please help me choose... again!
  61. Does the crop work?
  62. retouch to old picture - mono tone
  63. Which apple? Does more real=better?
  64. Removing elements in the picutre and changing color settings. Should I also crop it?
  65. Tubing on Winnipesaukee
  66. Rose
  67. B&W or Color - Critique
  68. Portrait CC please....
  69. First attempt at Fireworks
  70. Breaking the rule of thirds. Did it work?
  71. Back-lit Glasses -- v 1 or v 2? -- need some feedback.
  72. Outdoor portrait
  73. Which fireworks shot?
  74. Bridge over the Thames
  75. What would you do?
  76. Which composition?
  77. Before and After
  78. Boat: Color vs. B&W
  79. Moss Covered Ship
  80. b&w portrait, which crop?
  81. Can't decide on baby pic edit
  82. Two portraits of a Pirate - which one is better?
  83. Which crop is better?
  84. Settings when using lens adapter
  85. Cowgirl relaxing
  86. the color Green
  87. Ave of the palms
  88. Another color vs. black & white choice
  89. help me with the WB
  90. I went back to try again.....
  91. Paintbrush
  92. Which focus - tree or statue?
  93. Band Photo
  94. an ant's eye view
  95. Memorial Day parade
  96. Louisville Slugger
  97. I hate when I can't decide!
  98. natural or cross processed?
  99. Bw vs bw
  100. Color vs. BW
  101. Saturation Decision
  102. How is the post prod treatment?
  103. Rock climbing
  104. Senior Photos: classic or stylized..?
  105. Please help choose...two wacky fences
  106. Tinted B/W @ Low Opacity or Straight B/W??
  107. Window or No Window?
  108. Composition critique
  109. Crop
  110. black and white baseball or color
  111. Playing around with Aperture 3
  112. 9sec. Golden Gate Night Exposure
  113. SKYLINE or skyline
  114. Splash Colour or Retro B&W
  115. Your opinion on two different crops?
  116. Hobo Blanket?
  117. Raindrops
  118. leaf or no leaf?
  119. getting to grips with composition
  120. SSsslllllllliding FuN!
  121. Cavalier Macro Shot Edits
  122. Which one?
  123. Color or B&W?
  124. The Purple Flower
  125. Light or dark?
  126. Finally Captured one of the little B@5t@rds, Now wich crop?
  127. Saturation and Mood
  128. Old Painting Effect
  129. Eifel National Park - HDR
  130. which crop?
  131. Which one is more suitable?
  132. A Shared Moment - Which is better
  133. Vibrant colors or the subtlety of BW?
  134. Please help!
  135. Need help with eyes
  136. Cant decide which is better....
  137. To bleach or not to bleach??? Which edit is best?
  138. 1st Graveyard shoot
  139. Composition suggestions
  140. Message in a bottle
  141. First paid shoot! Which one is better?
  142. difference in the content of the pictures
  143. Too Blue?
  144. Which do you like?
  145. Lighthing a picture or not?
  146. Right direction with editing?
  147. Colors -- White balance
  148. Reality versus dreamworld
  149. Roundabout vs Roundabout
  150. Which One?
  151. 360º Panoramic vs mini globe
  152. Locks of Cologne - how is better?
  153. First Photoshop edit(on a photo i've never liked...)
  154. Restoring an old bad shap photo for friend
  155. Which one is better
  156. Two scenes of the same tree ...
  157. A Blank Canvas
  158. Colour or Black & White flowers?
  159. What is she looking at?
  160. B/W or Colour?
  161. How to improve?
  162. Color or B&W?
  163. A little help deciding please....
  164. Bloody Marit (don't worry, the blood is fake)
  165. Eyes Wide Shut?
  166. revisit of a wedding portrait
  167. Roundabout Comparisons...
  168. My nephew - post processing
  169. More or Less Contrast
  170. Great pose, how best to process
  171. This or that
  172. B&W or sepia??
  173. Opinions?
  174. Composition critique - tugboat & bridge
  175. Texture Fail
  176. photoshopping newb
  177. Please help I've lost all objectifity
  178. Orton Processed or Normal?
  179. Foreground or not
  180. This One or That One?
  181. Cropped or uncropped?
  182. Lighthouse & pier at night
  183. do you see improvement?
  184. To Bridge or Not...That is the Question!
  185. Two portrait compositions...
  186. Sunsets but which compositon?
  187. Dark Light - B&W or Colour?
  188. Old fellow
  189. better tree vs. better clouds
  190. color change
  191. Long exposure snow scene - warm or cold?
  192. Which crop?
  193. soft or sharp?
  194. Flatter? Steeper? Train in or out?
  195. which pie is better?
  196. Which Smoke Edit?
  197. Sparks
  198. Louvre - which is a better one
  199. Football - PS too much?
  200. Too much PP?
  201. one or two? u decide
  202. which one is better composed?
  203. Please help me to choose a crop
  204. Lonely Winter Day - Too much processing?
  205. Photographic Repair Comparison
  206. B&W Colorized Portrait
  207. Beware...naked baby, butt shot...lol
  208. Susquehanna river, PA at twilight
  209. Firewoman
  210. Volleyball Photo Critique
  211. Processed with LR for the Topaz Adjust look
  212. Getting some ice in the juice
  213. Christmas Star comparison
  214. Streetlamps: Which tells the better story?
  215. please be gentle, this is my first time.
  216. Subject on the left or the right?
  217. close up eyes
  218. Two very different edits
  219. Is there a clear winner, or are they both good for different reasons?
  220. Preferred Processing
  221. Color?
  222. Rocks in? Rocks out?
  223. more of a story
  224. edit or original?
  225. Chinese chess player, BW or colors ?
  226. Christmas Lights- Two Compositions
  227. newbie here
  228. Version 1 or version 2?
  229. Birthday Cake
  230. two different takes on a project
  231. Natural or Edited
  232. Same subject - Two different takes
  233. To vignette or not to vignette?
  234. Light vs. Dark
  235. Golden Haired Girl
  236. Nasturtium in pieces
  237. does this vingette work?
  238. Would like to hear/read your input..
  239. Focal Point and DoF differences - which draws the eye better?
  240. Just trash it?
  241. Expecting twins - full color or selective color?
  242. pop my cherry ;-)
  243. Hummingbirds
  244. Vote for which is better
  245. ultrawide, portrait or landscape
  246. 1 or 2? 1 or 2?
  247. Which Version?
  248. Color or BW?
  249. Brown Beauty on Bayou
  250. Gerberas - dappled or plain background!?