I sit firmly in the realistic HDR camp, I use HDR occasionally to bring out the detail in dark holes, but stay well away from tone mapping. That said, it's just reflective of my style of photography.
I think the "issue" with the original image is that it's not immediately evident if it's supposed to be a natural or obvious HDR image.
__________________
Neil
www.hargreavesphotography.com.au | Twitter | Blog | email
Canon 5D2 | Canon 50D | Canon 10D
17-40L | 24-70L | 35L | 70-200 f/2.8L IS | 100L Macro IS | 135L | 85/1.8 | Sigma 50/1.4 | Pocketwizards & other lighting stuff
|