View Single Post
  #1 (permalink)  
Old 08-13-2009, 02:54 AM
Grumby's Avatar
Grumby Grumby is offline
dPS Forum Member
 
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Sydney
Posts: 534
Default What functions do you lose with ext tubes?

I'm looking at getting some (cheap) extension tubes for my D40x and kit lenses (as described below - the 55-200 is a VR model), but I gather that without a means of continuing the electrical connections from body to lens, there will be some functionality lost... Is anyone able to qualify this?

My guesses are
  • no autofocus
  • no aperture control (no aperture rings on my lenses)
  • no vibration reduction (where this is in the lens rather than the sensor)

If I have no aperture control - does that mean all photos will be taken with max aperture?

Does anyone know if Nikon make a set of tubes that DOES continue the circuitry, and therefore eliminates the issues?

Cheers,
Grumby


Additional:
Just did a bit of legwork during lunch...
Local camera shop (Ted's) only sells a Kenko kit, which supports autofocus (not sure about other functionality), and costs AU$300
ebay has same kit available for about $175
ebay also has numerous 'cheapos' for around $20-50 which have no electrical pass through.

Additional additional:
Is it just the electrical connections between those contacts on the body and lens that need maintaining? I remember on my old Praktica SLR, there was a little thingy in the body that pushed against a little pin in the lens, that caused the iris to shut down when you triggered the shutter - but I guess that is all electronic these days...

I was wondering if I bought a cheapo set of tubes, and then hacked the Nikon specific mount parts by letting a small section of veroboard into each of them (carefully lined up with the contacts, obviously), and then ran a ribbon cable between the two (externally, so that I can still change the configuration of the tubes between the mounts), whether I could cobble together a cheap but fully AF compatible set of tubes? It seems that a hike from $20 to $300 is an awful lot just to provide 4 or 5 electrical connections between each tube!
__________________
My gear: Nikon D3000, 18-55 & 55-200 (kit), 50mm f/1.8, Fuji Finepix F20 P&S
My blog: My D3000 Diaries
My flickr Grumby and his D3000

They say the camera never lies - so it's obviously the world that is out of focus, not my photos...

Last edited by Grumby; 08-13-2009 at 04:09 AM. Reason: further info
Reply With Quote