Why I Switched From LEE Filters to Formatt-Hitech for Landscape Photography

0Comments
A hard graduated neutral density filter worked great here to darken the sky.

A hard graduated neutral density filter worked great here to darken the sky.

There are three types of photographers in the world; those that try to get it right in camera, those that simply rely on post-processing, and those who believe that both mindsets together lead to the best possible outcome. I try to always keep the mindset of that third type. If I can get everything right in camera (and save minutes or even hours in post) I will. I also have always loved post-processing and the art of making an image come to life. When shooting landscapes, you are more often than not at the mercy of mother nature. You can certainly schedule your time wisely and shoot at the best times of day but that doesn’t always mean that you’ll be able to capture everything in camera, as it is.

I’ve been using filters in one way or another for the better part of four years now. I started off with those bloody screw in filters (my gosh were those a pain in the rear). I remember very vividly just how frustrating it was to need a separate filter for each and every lens. I also remember how long it took to get to a scene, set up my tripod, look at the scene, decide I needed a filter, realize the filter I needed doesn’t fit the lens I had on, switch lenses, get the filter out of its case, screw it on, refocus and then finally take a shot.

I used a my Formatt-Hitech 105mm circular polarizer here to remove glare from the rocks and water. The images without the filter were virtually unusable.

I used a my Formatt-Hitech 105mm circular polarizer here to remove glare from the rocks and water. The images without the filter were virtually unusable.

My brief stint with LEE Filters

After giving up on the screw-in filters, I eventually discovered the LEE Filter system. Those LEE filters are dang near impossible to get your hands on. I had to put my name on a waiting list at a camera store just to get the foundation system to attach the filters to my lenses. I then had to buy my filters on eBay and pay over retail to get them. My absolute favorite filter from LEE was (and still is) the Big Stopper. The Big Stopper is a 10 stop neutral density filter that will slow your shutter speeds down by…well…10 stops. This is a long exposure filter that is meant to slow time down drastically. You can easily get one to two minute exposures in broad daylight. The problem with the Big Stopper is that it’s a glass filter. This means that you have to be very careful with it and any time it’s on your person, you have to be extra cautious.

This 2 minute exposure caused the hundreds of tourists in the scene to disappear completely! © James Brandon

This two minute exposure caused the hundreds of tourists in the scene to disappear completely! © James Brandon

So what went wrong with LEE? Well, I’ll tell you…

Back in 2013, I was in California and was traveling up the coast from San Luis Obispo to San Francisco with my buddy Brian Matiash. We made it up to Big Sur and were trying to get down to Pfeiffer Beach for sunset. As we made our way up Highway 1, we pulled over to photograph Big Creek Bridge. I decided to put my Big Stopper to good use and started grabbing some long exposures of the bridge with the waves crashing against the shore below. I got a few shots where I was standing but soon decided to switch lenses and try something else. When I’m out in the field and need to switch lenses, I always point my camera down to the ground so that minimal dust will get into the censor during the swap. I pointed the camera down toward the ground (while still on the tripod) and then reached for my filter pouch to take off my Big Stopper before changing lenses. That’s when it happened. I felt a big thud against my shoe and then heard the terrible sound of glass hitting the gravel beneath my feet. Ugh…

It turns out the LEE filter holder can’t support the weight of a heavy Big Stopper. I’m not sure if this is a design flaw or what, but it certainly seems like oversight to me. With LEE filters (just like Formatt-Hitech) you have to screw an adaptor onto the lens you’re using (I just leave these adaptors screwed on most of the time). The filter holder then clips onto the adaptor via a pull pin on one side. This pull pin is angled away from the lens to match the shape of the ring adaptor. Because of the angle of this pull pin, you can actually just pull the filter holder off of the adaptor with surprisingly little force. Of course this will never happen if your camera is pointed out toward the horizon, but who among us never points their camera down? I got lucky that day because the filter hit my shoe first before hitting the ground. It didn’t bust the entire filter but one of the corners did however get a big chunk taken out of it.

My introduction to Formatt-Hitech

Colby Brown has been a friend of mine for a couple years now. I met him during the very, very early days of Google+ when a group of five or six of us would do hangouts almost daily. I have had the pleasure of watching his career virtually explode over this time and was really excited to see him land a signature edition filter kit with Formatt-Hitech. I’ll be the first to admit, I was pretty skeptical about trying any other type of filter besides LEE. Still to this day, I love my Big Stopper. However, that “event” in Big Sur really left me uneasy and nervous about using the LEE holder. So when Colby offered to send me his kit to review, I said what the heck, let’s see how it stacks up (see what I did there?) against LEE.

Unboxing

Don’t worry, I’m not posting one of those monotonous unboxing videos where I show you how the filters were packaged or how much paperwork is included. I’m including this section because of one thing; when I pulled the Formatt-Hitech filter holder out of the box, I knew instantly that it was better than LEE. It just feels better. It’s aluminum instead of plastic for one, but on top of that – the filter holder has a fastening screw to attach to the adapter ring instead of the little notched pull tab that’s on the LEE system. At first I wasn’t really sure this would be any better because, after all, you’re essentially just tightening the filter holder onto the adapter ring with a single screw. As it turns out though, the filter holder fits very snuggly onto the adapter ring, so when you tighten the screw the filters aren’t going anywhere. It takes a very strong push to cause it to budge at all, and no amount of filters will ever weigh that much. The LEE, on the other hand, requires surprisingly little force (see the video above).

Quality between LEE and Formatt-Hitech

The Colby Brown Signature Edition Landscape Filter Kit comes with basically everything you need to get started and stay satisfied using filters in the field for a very long time. I went all out and got the 100mm Premier Kit which comes with two graduated ND filters, a 6 Stop ND filter, the aluminum filter holder and to top it all off, a 105mm circular polarizer. Everything in the kit is extremely high quality and I use the filters on virtually every photo trip I take.

In all honesty, there isn’t a massive difference in the quality of images that come from either filter. Some will disagree with me on this of course. The LEE Big Stopper puts out a very obvious blue color cast in your images while Formatt-Hitechs new Firecrest filters put out virtually zero color cast. I’m actually quite fond of that blue/cool color cast though and have left it in several of my images to some extent. It’s also very easy to correct with a simple white balance adjustment so I’ve never considered it a huge deal.

I used my Formatt-Hitech 105mm Circular Polarizer for this shot as well to remove the glare from the rocks in the foreground.

I used my Formatt-Hitech 105mm Circular Polarizer for this shot to remove the glare from the rocks in the foreground.

Where Formatt-Hitech wins

There are three main areas where Formatt-Hitech Filters excel and where LEE falls short.

  1. The first of those areas is the one I already covered; a superior filter holding system constructed of durable aluminum and a tightening mechanism that won’t fail in the field when pointed at a downward angle.
  2. The second area where Formatt-Hitech wins is availability. The simply produce and ship enough filters so photographers like you and me don’t have to be put on waiting lists, or pay over retail to acquire their products.
  3. The third reason Formatt-Hitech takes the cake is that they continue to push to boundaries of what filters can do. They continue to innovate and advance. Their new line of Firecrest filters can stop down a scene by up to 16 stops! That means you could shoot in broad daylight at f/8, ISO 100 and a shutter speed of 1/1000th of a second and as soon as you slide that filter on, you’re shutter speed will drop all the way down to 1 minute. That’s insane!
Here I used my 10 stop neutral density filter to slow the shutter speed way down. This was a 25 second exposure taken before sunset. The clouds coming over the Sierras in the background is actually smoke from the rim fire that occurred back in 2013.

Here I used my 10 stop neutral density filter to slow the shutter speed way down. This was a 25 second exposure taken before sunset. The clouds coming over the Sierras in the background is actually smoke from the rim fire that occurred back in 2013.

Conclusion

Both LEE and Formatt-Hitech make great filters (although Formatt-Hitech has a slight edge in my opinion). However, the fact that I simply can’t trust the filter holder from LEE was enough to make me look at other options. Sure, I could have just stuck with LEE filters and got a new filter holder system, but I like to be all in with the brands I associate with in the industry. The failure of the LEE system caused me to look into Formatt-Hitechs options and when I did, I was pleasantly surprised to find a superior company making superior products. I’m not sponsored by Formatt-Hitech, I just honestly believe their products are top notch. Let me know if you have any questions below.

Summary
Review Date
Reviewed Item
Formatt-Hitech Filter System
Author Rating
5

Read more from our Cameras & Equipment category

James Brandon

is a landscape photographer and educator residing in Dallas, Texas. Join 20,000+ photographers and get access to his free video tutorial library at his website. James also has an online store full of video courses, ebooks, presets and more. Use the coupon code “DPS25” for an exclusive discount!

  • Rachel Wei

    I am having the same issue with the Lee holder, and not so lucky the filter dropped on the rocks and cracked. Almost debating getting a screw on until I read this and thinking of switching over to Hitech. I am also having issue with different thickness of the filters, the 16 stops that I have is thicker than 10 stop, so I will have to use screw driver to tighten for the Lee system, but it seems Hitech has front screw that would make it easier to tighten the filters on the spot. I was wondering if my 82mm adapter from Lee would work on Hitech as well?

  • Joel Sjaarda

    Thanks for your interesting write-up. Your 3rd point is the only one that I can agree with, but I’d say that Singh-Ray is also doing great things with filters as well. I’ve never had problems with the strength of my Lee filter kit, and it’s easy to get Lee Filters here in Toronto (Technically Yours Inc.). That being said, they are expensive and I do scratch them and buy new ones all the time. I’ve probably spent about 4k on filters over the past 4 years, but that comes with the territory of adventure landscape photography. Right now, I’d still say that Lee and Singh-Ray have the best filters in the business. However, I enjoyed reading about your experience with filters. Take care James!

  • JuanMa

    I found that Colby Brown has his own Signature Edition of Landscape Filter Kit with Formatt Hitech but in his photos in action on the field, he is using Lee Filter. This triggered me a question about how committed with his Signature Edition he is and why. Despite of that I bought his Signature Premier Edition and is on the way. Let’s see the quality once I have them and tested on the field.

  • ernldo

    You drop your filter and blame Lee? I have had NO issues with my FK holder, whats more is the Big Stopper has a light sealing material ringing the filter, and MINE fits solidly into the holder. Also, the only Lee I ever waited for was the Big Stopper, and that was about a month’s wait with B&H…WORTH every second and dollar paid.
    This was merely a HiTech ad….

  • liewwk

    I have no problem with the Lee Filter Foundation after used for 5-6 years … Hitech seem have green cast which difficult to correct compare to blue cast … and now I am combine HAIDA ND and LEE FILTERS GND .. think still best option around

  • Andy Aveyard

    “It turns out the LEE filter holder can’t support the weight of a heavy Big Stopper” This happened to me too and I was gutted. I’ve since bought a Firecrest 10 stop after reading some reviews, I’m using it in conjunction with my Lee filter holder. I’ve only taken a couple of shots so far, on very dull days too, but I do see a slight purple cast along the edges of my images. I don’t know if this is a light leak, or a characteristic of the Firecrest filter?

  • Prof.

    Hi James, thanks a lot for the comprehensive article.

    I have a question that despite searching throughout the internet I have not come across a satisfactory answer. Last weekend I was on a hike and for just few minutes I kept two of my brand new Lee GNDs in the pocket of my hiking pants. Well, both filters got badly scratched creating a spot in the middle of the gradient area! I am a super careful person, I watch out my gear and the pocket is padded and of course free of any items. And still.. they scratched!

    My questions are:
    – Do you have any experience with the new Firecrest series of Formatt Hitech? How would you value them in terms of scratch resistance?
    – What would you recommend as a scratch-free (but not necessarily more fragile) system to use hand held and to keep easily accessible on a hiking tour?

    As a materials scientist myself, I am wondering: It should not be so difficult to create resin filters that have suitable anti-scratch coatings…..

    Thanks in advance for your reply.

  • anewman80

    One thing I wonder is whether the Hitech super slim Firecrest polariser vignettes at 16mm, on either the Lee holder with wide angle adapter or any other holder. Apparently the Lee landscape polariser doesn’t.

  • I recently found the the Lee C-PL 105mm Filter on the front holder reflects the white font on my 18mm Zeiss Batis back onto the image!! My images now have a circular ‘Distagon 2 8/18 O77’

  • Except I got an email shortly after writing this article from a LEE employee acknowledging the issue with the filter holder and letting me know they were working on a fix. I had NO issue with my holder either until the holder fell off the adapter ring.

    It gets so old seeing comments where just because I’m saying something critical of one product and favorable of another, that it must be an ad for the latter.

    OR, I’m a writer for DPS and do articles from time to time about the gear I use and the experiences I have with it.

  • Mike

    I know that this is an old thread, but just wanted to share my experience with the Lee holder. I have never had the problem in which you have described here, and as mentioned before the holder still takes a considerable amount of force to dislodge, certainly more than enough to hold my Big Stopper plus two more filters with ease. However, the problem that I had on one of my shoots was the spring loaded pull tab come apart and my filters and holder dropped into the water at the beach. I still use the Lee system, but that has always been something that I have to pay attention to in case it happens again.

  • rooofooo

    Really?? Was thinking to get the lee kit with the 105mm CP.. Maybe use a black permanet marker over the white letters would work:D

Join Our Email Newsletter

Thanks for subscribing!


DPS offers a free weekly newsletter with: 
1. new photography tutorials and tips
2. latest photography assignments
3. photo competitions and prizes

Enter your email below to subscribe.
Email:
 
 
Get DAILY free tips, news and reviews via our RSS feed