sky replacement

[edmDusty]

This is just a quick photo I took to practice sky replacement. What do you think? Does the sky look real. Or can you tell I replaced it?

[jdepould]

Moved to processed photo critique.

[JGennuso]

The sky totally looks real! Nice job.

[windrider86]

[I]t does look great. Can only slighlty tell if you zoom in real close by the edges that dont quite match up.. That can easily be fixed by using the smudge tool.

[OsmosisStudios]

The sky itself is fine, but it doesnt match the scene in the least. The lighting, shadows, colour, etc are all wrong.

[edmDusty]

Lighting, contour, color. What's wrong with them? How do if fix it?

[edmDusty]

I worked on a few more skies. Any of these look any better?

#1


#2


#3


#4

[Nathan deGargoyle]

#4 is defnitely the best shot. I wouldn't have guessed you had photo$hopped it unless you had said!

But I think what OS meant was that you have to look at where the light was coming from in your original shot and find a sky where the light is coming from the same direction.