I'm not sure which of those two photos I like more. I like the colours of the left photo, but I also like the contrasty look of the right photo. The right photo also makes her eyes come out better, and I've got the feeling the highlights are more in control.
Which edit do you like better? And most importantly: why?
If you want to know how I took this photo, check out
this post in the "How I Took It" forum.