Art is subjective at best, so we shouldn’t put to much in “Theories” or “Rules” (which ARE made to be broken), and in what others think.

Input is VERY helpful, at least to know what people think , and for help in getting better, but use it as a guideline.

Do what you want, when and how you want … if it makes you happy.

Thanks again for the positive comments. Most people have said it’s to bad I couldn’t have taken the photo without the tree in the middle of the field? Like what, I’m going to go out there and cut it down?

Skip

Here are a few that don’t appear to well balanced.

-
-

This one is a tough one. Several people have told me it’s not “centered” well. The tree in the middle is “Off” some say.
-

That said, I completely agree about reviewing your past work – I notice for example how much less I crop images in post production these days compared to a few years ago. The cropping process taught me a lot about how to think about the final image before pressing the shutter button!